The Why And How of Alternative Investments in Retirement Plans

It requires balancing diversification needs with fiduciary and operational considerations.

By Amy Reuter, Senior Vice President and Trust Officer at Matrix Trust Company, a Broadridge  company

This article originally appeared in the Fall 2026 issue of ASPPA’s Plan Consultant magazine.

Are we moving into an era of alts for everyone? As traditional investments have become more concentrated and correlated in recent years, alternative asset classes are attracting increased attention.

The range of non-traditional assets is broad, encompassing everything from hedge funds to privately traded investments to digital assets such as cryptocurrencies.

Within this universe, many investors have been drawn to the expanded opportunity set and enhanced diversification potentially offered by private markets investments.

Alternative investments are no longer a fringe topic in the defined contribution market.

As private markets and other non-traditional strategies move further into the institutional mainstream, 401(k) plan sponsors, advisors, and recordkeepers are asking a more practical question: not only whether alternatives belong in retirement plans, but how to make them available in ways that work within the DC system.

Building the DC Plan Menu of Tomorrow

For retirement plan recordkeepers, plan sponsors, and plan advisors, evaluating whether to make investments beyond traditional ones available requires balancing diversification needs with fiduciary and operational considerations. Alternative investments may offer benefits in diversifying opportunities.

The growing interest in alternatives in 401(k) plans reflects several broader market shifts. Institutional investors have used alternatives for years to diversify risk, pursue returns beyond public markets, and gain access to different economic exposures.

At the same time, concerns about the long-term outlook for traditional stock and bond portfolios have prompted sponsors and advisors to revisit what a modern retirement menu should look like.

Data Callout

  • Allocations to private investments could reach 6.1% of all DC plan assets, or $1 trillion by 2030.¹
  • Within a decade, up to one-fifth of DC plans could have exposure to private market investments.²

Expanding Investment Offerings Responsibly

While the trend toward private investments in DC plans is gaining momentum, recordkeepers, plan sponsors, administrators and advisors need to tread carefully.

Expanding exposure to alternative investments requires balancing participant demand with fiduciary responsibilities and the operational realities of retirement plans.

A Roadmap for Considering Non-Traditional Assets

In the DC market, a strategy must also be tradable, valued, administered, and communicated in ways that align with participant-directed plan design. For those considering non-traditional assets for their plan menus, two key questions can help inform the right choice for plan participants.

1. Are non-traditional investments a good fit for the plan?

Start by considering plan participants – their demographics, financial sophistication and their long-term investment goals. Participants’ needs should drive these decisions. Plan fiduciaries should consider whether:

  • Non-traditional and private investments are appropriate for participants’ retirement goals.
  • Participants have the requisite investment experience and financial resources to invest in these asset classes.
  • There is sufficient demand among participants for these types of investments.
  • The investment vehicle is appropriate for participants and their investment experience.

A disciplined, well-documented evaluation process can help plan fiduciaries demonstrate that they have fulfilled their fiduciary responsibilities.

2. What’s the right way to access these asset classes?

Next, seek out investment vehicles that offer exposure to non-traditional investments in a way that fits into the DC operational framework.

Recordkeepers best positioned for this shift will be those that focus not just on product availability, but on operational readiness. Supporting alternatives in DC plans means supporting the trading, valuation, reporting, participant communication, and fiduciary processes that make those products usable in the first place.

Consider whether investments:

  • Trade in large, liquid markets and settle in T+1, so participants can easily buy and sell any of the holdings in their plan account.
  • Price daily for recordkeepers to accurately value participants’ accounts and process trades.
  • Provide fee transparency and performance information to help investors make informed decisions.

Depending on a plan’s objectives and participants’ experience levels, non-traditional investments may be accessed through structures designed to meet retirement plan operational requirements, coupled with portfolio management options. These various options include:

  • Mutual funds and ETFs: Non-traditional exposure can be introduced into diversified portfolios without requiring recordkeepers to reinvent plan operations.
  • Collective Investment Trusts (CITs): Pooled assets bring scale from multiple plans, potentially providing access to a wider range of non-traditional investment options while fitting into the existing operational workflow.
  • Unitized or Managed Accounts: Unitizing accounts aligns with the existing operational structure for pricing, cash management, and reconciliation while making non-traditional assets available within a professionally overseen portfolio framework.
  • Self-Directed Brokerage Accounts: SDBAs provide another avenue for access, particularly for more engaged and sophisticated participants who want investments beyond the core menu.

For some plans, access for a broad participant population may look different than access designed for a smaller group of more sophisticated investors.

Self-Directed Brokerage Accounts May Offer a Compromise

To meet the needs of sophisticated plan participants seeking greater exposure to non-traditional investments, consider providing the option to invest through a self-directed brokerage account (SBDA).

An SBDA can empower more experienced investors to access the unique attributes of non-traditional assets without requiring an overhaul of the larger plan.

Depending on their asset levels, participants may be able to allocate a portion of their plan contributions to private placements and other less liquid investment vehicles.

Adding an SBDA to a DC plan can give eligible participants the freedom to invest according to their needs and preferences.

Enhanced Potential. Increased Responsibilities.

The future of alternative investments in DC plans will depend not only on whether plan sponsors and participants want them but also whether the industry can deliver them in participant-friendly, plan-compatible structures.

While non-traditional investments may offer attractive diversification, they also require plan fiduciaries to commit to careful suitability analysis, asset class and investment selection, and ongoing monitoring.

Supporting these investments requires additional capabilities and expertise. This can put pressure on providers to understand how to deliver access to non-traditional investments. Fortunately, recordkeepers and plan fiduciaries don’t have to do it alone. Experienced providers can play a central role to help determine which pathways are practical and scalable.

Ultimately, each plan’s approach should reflect its participant demographics, fiduciary responsibilities and operational needs.

For plans that determine private and non-traditional investments are appropriate, access to the right expertise and resources can help support informed decisions and ongoing oversight.

Sources

¹ Wealth Management, “Deloitte: Private Market Allocations in DC Plans Could Hit $1T by 2030,” Elaine Misonzhnik, May 20, 2026.

² Source: Wealth Management, “Cerulli: Up to One-Fifth of DC Plans Might Invest in Private Markets by 2035,” Elaine Misonzhnik, January 8, 2026.

 

What's next for your business?

We want to hear more about what you need to improve your business and drive transformative innovation, efficiency, and growth.
required
required
required
required
required
required
required
required
By proceeding, you agree that Broadridge can use your personal information to respond to your inquiry and send you occasional updates about Broadridge solutions and thought leadership. You can unsubscribe from our communications at any time. To learn more, view our Privacy Statement.
Want to speak with a specialist?
North America
+1 800 353 0103(option 3)
Hong Kong +852 3004 3094
Singapore +65 31 351 278